My issue is your flat out wrong assertion that he is 1) too small, and 2) drops too many passes. Those are just wrong. Watch the tape. I went back and did, why don't you?
And of course, use the homer card when all other arguments fail. Such a convenient card to play. Notice I never once disputed your assessment of Barkley in this thread.
But I can easily play that game too. Leave it to the admitted USC hater for saying a 6'1'' WR with one of the surest hands in the country is too small and drops too many passes.
RD, who has known me for years, could tell you I've always had a very fair assessment on USC guys. I'm not always right, but I'm always fair.